1986 –
Mike Ericson, Harper Woods Bishop Gallagher1987 – Dan Hilliard, Monroe
1988 – Steve Avery, Taylor Kennedy
1989 – Steve Nowak, Gaylord St. Mary
1990 – Aaron Knieper, Saginaw Nouvel Catholic
1991 – Ron Hollis, Brighton
1992 – Derek Jeter, Kalamazoo Central
1993 – Jason Middlebrook, Grass Lake
1994 – Dave Kauflin, Mt. Clemens Chippewa Valley
1995 – J.J. Putz, Trenton
1996 – Matt Sheets, Jenison
1997 – Ryan Kyes, Detroit Country Day
1998 – Drew Henson, Brighton
1999 – Casey Rogowski, Redford Detroit Catholic Central
2000 – Scott Koerber, Grosse Pointe North (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2000 – Nate McLouth, Whitehall (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2001 – Jon Koch, Berrien Springs
2002 – Chris Getz, Grosse Pointe South (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2002 – Randy Frye, Lake Orion (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2003 – Nick Thurman, Warren Mott
2004 – Doug Pickens, Birmingham Brother Rice
2005 – Zach Putnam, Ann Arbor Pioneer
2006 – Dale Cornstubble, Homer (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2006 – Dan Holcomb, Homer (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2007 – D.J. Lemahieu, Birmingham Brother Rice
2008 – William Arnold, Mt. Pleasant (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2008 – Tyler Mills, Mt. Pleasant (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2009 – Daniel Fields, University of Detroit Jesuit
2010 – Alex Zeiher, Saline
2011 – Eric Haase, Dearborn Divine Child
2012 – Justin Alleman, Holt (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2012 – Alex Darr, Grosse Pointe University Liggett (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2013 – Carmen Benedetti, Grosse Pointe South (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2013 – Jackson Lamb, Temperance-Bedford (Co-Mr. Baseball)
2014 – Zack McGuire, Sterling Heights Stevenson
2015 – Nick Plummer, Birmingham Brother Rice
2016 – John Baker, Hartland
2016 – Tommy Henry, Portage Northern
2017 – Sam Weatherly, Howell